| Today
we are celebrating the Feast of St. Hilary, our
Patron. It seems a good thing, to me, to take time,
once in a while, to remember who this man was. We
attend a church which is named in his honor. If
this church was named with any more care than one
might name a store, then being the Church of St.
Hilary must have some meaning.
Hilary isn't the most well known of all the saints.
Although he is considered one of the greatest theologian-saints
in the calendar. I'm sure you've gotten the question,
as I do nearly every Sunday, "Who was St. Hilary?"
Or even, "What did she do?" And we've
all heard jokes confusing his name with a certain
public figure with the feminine version of the same
name.
So, who was St. Hilary and why should we care that
we call ourselves by his name?
Hilary was born in Poitiers in what is now France
in 315. He died there in either 367 or 368 (whether
on November 1 or January 13 is open for debate.)
He was named a saint shortly after his death and
was declared a "Doctor of the Divinity of Christ"
by Pope Pius IX in 1851. His feast day is now celebrated
on January 13.
Hilary was born into a wealthy, pagan family. He
studied rhetoric and philosophy and was known as
an orator He married and had a daughter now known
as Saint Afra. He experienced conversion in his
mid-thirties and was baptized along with his wife
and daughter. He was made bishop of Poitiers in
353. (According to one source, he and his wife had
to live separately so that he could be ordained.
Quite a sacrifice on both of their parts.)
There was a major controversy raging in the Church
in the 4th century between those that claimed that
Jesus was both fully human and fully divine - he
was of the same substance as God the Father - and
those that claimed he was not as divine as God the
Father - he was of a similar substance. This has
become known as the Arian controversy. Most of the
Orthodox theology (Jesus was God) was being promoted
in the eastern and Greek speaking part of the world.
Most of western Latin speaking, Europe was Arian
(Jesus was like God). Hilary was the first theologian
to argue for orthodoxy using western thought, philosophy,
culture and language.
His orthodox stance caused him to be exiled for
several years. It was during his exile that he did
most of his writing on the Trinity and on the theology
of the church. While in exile, he was never replaced
as bishop of Poitiers because the priests would
rather "pretend he was still there" rather
than risk getting someone they didn't want. He was
returned to his diocese in 360, mainly because he
was causing so much trouble in Phrygia where he
had been sent that the Arian bishops asked that
he be returned.
Hilary was a prolific writer and poet and was one
of the earliest hymn writers. Although he is not
one of the most well known of historical theologians,
his influence was vast. He was a contemporary of
Athanasius. He was Martin of Tours' spiritual director
and guide. St. Jerome considered Hilary an inspiration.
I believe that it would be safe to say that if it
weren't for the determination, persuasive abilities
and courage of Hilary of Poitiers, Arianism would
have captured the day in western Europe. It is probably
in great part, because of Hilary that western Europe,
and therefore we, have grown up in a faith that
claims that Jesus Christ is the Son of God and in
fact is true God of True God.
Hilary is the patron saint of those bitten by snakes
and learning disabled children and according to
some sources, of lawyers. There is a legend that
while visiting an island off the coast of France,
Hilary ran all of the snakes into the sea (an incredibly
similar legend to that of Patrick of Ireland). Hilary's
bed was kept on display in the Cathedral of Poitiers
for years. It was said that if a "madman"
were to spend a night in the "cradle of St.
Hilary" he would be cured.
In art work, Hilary is often pictured with three
books, a pen, a snake, a cradle or with Martin of
Tours. Our window in the back of the church, pictures
him in the Eucharistic vestments of a bishop with
three books, a pen and a snake.
When this congregation was being formed in 1958
the founding men and women looked for a name that
would capture the spirit that was driving them to
start a new church way down south of Fort Myers.
It seems that several lawyers were involved in the
early settlement of this congregation and in fact
have been throughout our history. So, Hilary, because
of his connection to lawyers, was chosen as our
patron. We are one of 3 St. Hilary's Episcopal Churches
in the U.S., although there are some Roman Catholic
Churches in the US and several in Europe.
So now that we know who Hilary was and how we came
to be called by his name, why should we care that
we are St. Hilary's Episcopal Church? Is St. Hilary
relevant to our life and times, or is he simply
a name from the past?
Hilary lived in a time of great upheaval in the
church. There were two distinct camps in the church.
Both, of course, thought they were right and the
other not only wrong, but evil. People died over
this dispute. Churches split. Hilary lost his job,
his home, his friends. The issue was vitally important.
Was Jesus divine or not. Kind of central to our
faith.
Hilary lived among people that believed differently
than he. Yet he found a way to maintain his faith,
and to share it. His efforts changed the shape of
history.
You know, in retrospect, we've done alright with
Jesus is God. I think if we had ended up with the
Arian faith that Jesus was like God, we'd find ourselves
like the Buddhist with a special holy man and a
great philosophy of living. But, it wouldn't be
the dynamic faith we have today.
There are a whole bunch of really holy people out
there. Gandhi was, I believe a gift from God to
all of us, but he didn't rise from the dead nor
promise that we would live forever. Luther was a
holy man, but he wasn't the perfect man. There are
those who died for their faith like Dietrich Bonhoeffer.
But, his death didn't free us from anything.
The first cornerstone of our faith is that God humbled
himself to come as a powerless, helpless baby. Fully
human and fully divine. Jesus Christ is the perfect
man. He is the image of God in which we were made.
This perfect man died so that we would go to heaven
when we die. No philosophy or even martyrdom can
do that. Jesus can because he is the very Son of
God.
It is frightening to think that our faith of today
hinged on the vote of 318 bishops in a dank cathedral
in what is now Turkey. It wasn't unanimous. We believe
that the Holy Spirit was present and guided the
minds of the victors. But did the Holy Spirit Passover
the Arians?
Hmmmm. The more things change, the more they stay
the same. Except in the case of faith communities
where one person has the final say on doctrine,
Christian doctrine has been decided by some sort
of consensus or vote. Gene Robinson is a bishop
because a majority of people in New Hampshire and
the General Convention of 2003 voted that he should
be. We use the 1979 Book of Common Prayer because
a majority of deputies to the 1976 and 1979 General
Conventions voted it so. Those of us who lament
either of these decisions no doubt feel that the
Holy Spirit was not heeded, while those of us who
welcome these actions believe they were led by the
Holy Spirit.
I think it a dangerous thing if we determine the
will of God by a vote. So what we do is determine
the doctrine of the Church hoping that we have discerned
God's Will. The Church, being made up of imperfect
people has made mistakes along the way. The inquisition,
the crusades, the trial of Galileo. Objectively
observed failures. Other doctrinal decisions aren't
so cut and dried. Up to 1990, I was vehemently opposed
to the ordination of women to the priesthood. I've
turned 180 degrees. Did the Holy Spirit wait until
seminary to visit me? I doubt it. More likely, it
wasn't until 1990 that I allowed the Holy Spirit
to talk to me about that subject.
I think it's important to note that the Arians of
Hilary's day didn't go off and form another religion.
They stayed, for the most part, within the One,
Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church. Why? I'm not
sure, but I would think it was because they knew
that the Church was about more than this doctrine,
as important as it was.
I have been asked why I believe being a part of
the Episcopal Church and participating with our
time and money is important even in the face of
sea changes in theology and practice. It is because
I believe that the Episcopal Church is about more
than the issues being debated.
God guided the 4th century church through horrible
division and strife and led us, as imperfect as
the church is, to what it is today. Nothing less
than the hope of salvation rested in the hands
of 318 men. Thank God, one of them was Hilary.
|